I love my AppleTV. Or, rather, I love the idea of my AppleTV. The idea of being able to stream movies and TV shows from some external drive buried on the far side of the house straight to the living room…awesome.
And for the most part, the AppleTV does the job. But it has it’s share of shortcomings all the same. The lack of horsepower to adequately run Boxee, for instance. Or the ridiculously fickle support for video formats (which my recent hacking has improved…somewhat). Or the fact that it has to stream through another computer that’s running iTunes, which in my house means I need two computers up and running if I want to watch something – one running iTunes and the other doing file server duty.
It’s occurred to me in the past that the Mac Mini would be the ideal solution to all of the AppleTV’s shortcomings, for a variety of reasons:
- Local Storage – Even the lowest-spec Mac Mini has a pretty decent hard drive, and with USB drives the sky is pretty much the limit. With the drives I already have on hand, I could have over 1TB of storage without the hassle of having to stream over Wi-Fi (which would have the side benefit of letting me export shows from the TiVo at much higher quality levels).
- Horsepower - The AppleTV runs on a 1GHz Pentium M processor and 256MB of RAM. No wonder it can be such a dog. A Mac Mini with a 2GHz Core 2 Duo and 2GB of RAM would more than blow it out of the water, making apps like Boxee actually useful.
- Native iTunes – If you want to stream over the AppleTV, the host computer has to a) be on and b) have iTunes running. With the Mac Mini, that wouldn’t be an issue. It could be managed directly, and attached storage would clear up any streaming headaches.
- Format Support – Even with my handy Video Converter app, there’s no guarantee that anything not actually purchased off iTunes will play over the AppleTV. The Mac Mini would offer much greater flexibility in which video formats it could play. Again, fewer headaches.
- A Keyboard – The most annoying thing about the AppleTV? When it drops wireless and you have to go back in and reenter your network password with the damn remote. This simply wouldn’t be an issue with the keyboard-supporting Mac Mini.
- More than just Music & Video – The Mac Mini is an honest-to-goodness Mac, and as such can do a lot more than just play stuff. Think web browsing, e-mail-checking, Pandora-playing goodness.
But today, I learned about yet another reason…the new Hulu Desktop app, which packages Hulu in a pretty full-screen wrapper than you can navigate with the Apple Remote (or in my case, a Logitech Harmony acting like an Apple Remote). This in essence means the realization of what Boxee has been trying to do for the last several months – bring the awesomeness of Hulu to the TV.
It’s not that the AppleTV is bad…it’s that a Mac Mini would just be so much more…capable.
Posted by Matt
Posted by Matt 
Posted by Matt 
- 

